When Restaurants Fight Back: A Diner’s Failed Attempt to Sue a Food Critic for Defamation

by

23 November 2024

Legal

food critic

Restaurant reviews can make or break your business.

A positive review of your restaurant can keep your cash counter busy and tables filled with loud and happy customers. But, a negative review does the complete opposite, leaving hardly any cash to collect and fewer tables to clean. 

Food critics hold power, and restaurants know it. Some establishments accept criticism and learn from it. Others take a more aggressive approach that can backfire badly.

This is what happened to a well-known diner when they decided to fight back against a food critic. The results were not what they expected.

The Case of Il Giardino

A Vancouver-based Italian restaurant, Il Giardino, was a local favorite. It’s known for its classic pasta dishes and cozy atmosphere. But in 2011, the restaurant’s reputation was challenged. The trouble began when a respected food critic, Colin Thomas, wrote a review that painted the restaurant in a negative light. He described the food as bland, overpriced, and lacking the warmth it once had.

The owners of Il Giardino were furious. They felt that Thomas’ words were not just harsh but unfair and damaging. They believed his review crossed the line and hurt their business. So, they decided to take legal action and sue him for defamation.

The Lawsuit That Backfired

The Lawsuit That Backfired

This lawsuit was something new and big news indeed. It’s not every day that you get to see a restaurant sue a critic.

Many people were curious about how it would turn out. The owners argued that the review was defamatory and claimed it had caused them to lose customers and money.

But fighting a food critic in court is tricky. Critics are protected under free speech laws. The court decided that Thomas’ review was an opinion, not a statement of fact. It didn’t meet the standard for defamation. The case was dismissed.

Instead of fixing their problem, Il Giardino made it worse. The lawsuit brought more attention to the bad review. News outlets covered the story, and people talked about it on social media. What might have been forgotten in a week was now in the spotlight for months. The restaurant’s online reputation suffered more than it did from the original review.

Why Suing Critics Is Risky

When a restaurant fights back, it backfires on them. And it’s not really a smart move to sue a food critic. Here’s why –

1. Freedom of Speech

Critics have the right to share their opinions. If a review is based on an experience and doesn’t include false claims, it is protected as free speech. Courts are careful about setting a precedent that could limit this freedom.

2. The Streisand Effect

Trying to silence a critic can lead to more attention. This is known as the Streisand Effect, named after Barbra Streisand, who tried to hide photos of her home but ended up drawing more attention to them. The same happened to Il Giardino. Their attempt to stop the review only made it more popular.

3. Public Backlash

People don’t like it when businesses try to suppress opinions. It can make a restaurant look like it can’t handle criticism or is trying to bully a writer. This can lead to backlash and damage a brand’s reputation.

Lessons Learned from the McDonald’s Case

Even major brands like McDonald’s have faced backlash for going after critics. In 1990, McDonald’s sued two environmental activists in the UK for distributing pamphlets that accused the company of poor practices. The case became known as the “McLibel” trial and lasted ten years.

The outcome? A PR disaster for McDonald’s. The activists couldn’t pay damages, but they won public support. McDonald’s spent millions on legal fees and looked like the villain. The company’s reputation took a hit, showing that even large corporations can face consequences when they overreact to criticism.

How to Handle Criticism as a Restaurant?

It’s not uncommon these days for a brand to get backlash from critics or customers. But how they handle it makes all the difference. Some of the tactics below work really well to handle criticism:

1. Respond Calmly and Professionally

A calm response can go a long way. Thank the critic for their feedback and mention any changes you plan to make. This shows that the restaurant values customer opinions and is willing to improve.

2. Focus on Positive Reviews

A bad review hurts, but it doesn’t define a restaurant. Focus on encouraging happy customers to leave positive reviews. A mix of reviews shows that a restaurant is real and popular. According to BrightLocal, 87% of consumers read online reviews for local businesses. A few negative reviews won’t hurt as much if there are plenty of positive ones.

3. Improve Feedback

Sometimes, criticism has truth in it. Look at what the critic pointed out and see if there are ways to improve. This can help turn a negative into a positive. It shows customers that the restaurant listens and evolves.

4. Invest in Online Reputation Management

If a bad review is causing ongoing issues, using an online reputation management service can help. These services can guide a restaurant on how to boost its online image and deal with negative press.

Recommendations for Restaurant Owners

Before your business has to handle something as harsh, it’s better to build some ground rules that keep your business away from such events. 

Think Before Reacting

It’s natural to feel upset after reading a harsh review, but it’s important to think before acting. Responding to anger or taking legal action can lead to bigger problems.

Provide Exceptional Customer Service

The foundation for a good business reputation starts with a business capability of delivering class-A customer service.

So, start by training your team. Warm and attentive staff attract more customers and build a good impression about your restaurant among clients. With open communication, your staff will take the business extra mile and exceed customer expectations. 

Communicate with Your Team

Make sure your team knows how to handle criticism. Training staff to respond professionally and with empathy can keep the restaurant’s image strong.

Don’t Compromise in the Food Quality

If the raw materials start to cost more, your customers may understand if the price goes high by a little. But, lowering food quality to adjust food prices can do damage to your restaurant in the long run. Always use fresh and high-quality ingredients to make food. Consistency in the quality of your food is the key to how you will succeed.

Stay Engaged with Customers

Interact with customers on review sites and social media. Show that you care about their experiences, good or bad. This connection can build loyalty and encourage repeat visits.

The Takeaway

Il Giardino’s attempt to sue a food critic for defamation is a reminder that fighting criticism can often make things worse. Publicly challenging a review can lead to more attention, public backlash, and damage to a business’s reputation.

Instead, restaurants should focus on learning from criticism and responding professionally. Encouraging positive feedback and engaging with customers can help maintain a strong image. And when extra help is needed, an online reputation management service can provide the right support.

In the end, handling criticism with grace and using it as a tool for improvement will benefit a restaurant far more than a court case ever could.

Read Also:

A passionate writer and an avid reader, Soumava is academically inclined and loves writing on topics requiring deep research. Having 3+ years of experience, Soumava also loves writing blogs in other domains, including digital marketing, business, technology, travel, and sports.

View all posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related

Family Lawyer

3 Reasons Why You Might Need a Family Lawyer

There are many situations where you might need to hire an experienced family lawyer, but we have listed three that are fairly common through the divorce process. If you find yourself in any of these situations, we highly suggest that you work with a family lawyer in Miami instead of attempting to deal with the Florida family courts alone. Divorces can be complicated and confusing, but if you have the legal counsel of an experienced attorney, your complications can be reduced and your legal process can be a lot smoother. 1. Paperwork: When you begin the process of a divorce, one of the first things you will realize is that there is an exceptional amount of paperwork and documentation required, beginning with your Petition for a Dissolution of Marriage. Once your divorce is underway, you will need to present extensive financial documentation, information about property ownership, receipts for expenses, and more. When you are working with a qualified attorney, you can be certain that you are providing all of the necessary information to the courts or your spouse's attorney in order to make the process as smooth as possible. Divorces are stressful even with the help of an attorney, but it can be even more complicated when you are continuously worried about whether or not you are following the necessary procedures and covering all of your bases. 2. Access to Experts: Your attorney will be qualified and experienced, but this experience will also give them insight into when they need to bring in their own outside counsel. Although you would also be able to find your own experts for various roadblocks you encounter while trying to manage a divorce on your own, you can be sure that a divorce lawyer has a very broad network that they can access. This means that, along with the abilities of your lawyer, you will also have access to their experts in all sorts of fields. This can be a major benefit in a complex divorce, and when your attorney is the one sourcing the experts, it will save you a lot of time. 3. Understanding Your Options: When first entering a divorce, it may be hard to understand the options that you have. For example, you will be required to divide all of your marital assets, navigate child custody and support questions, and possibly negotiate alimony for either or your spouse. When you are working with a family lawyer, they will be able to lay out all of the important factors early in the case, which will help you move through each with objectivity and without being too overwhelmed. In addition to laying out your expectations, they will be able to negotiate for you each step of the way through these options. Beyond these three simple reasons that you will want to hire a family lawyer to help you through your divorce, there are many other benefits. If you are making negotiations with your spouse and their lawyer, you want to be sure that you have a legal professional looking out for your best interest so you do not agree to anything because you are not sure if you have other options. Your lawyer is there to solely represent you in this divorce, and having an objective counsel through this stressful period of time can be exceptionally helpful. Read Also: 4 Tips For Dealing With A Family Business In Divorce 6 Ways To Heal After Divorce From An Emotionally Abusive Marriage

READ MOREDetails
Ideas

How to Protect your Ideas

Now in the age of internet and boom of entrepreneurial spirit, people seek and brainstorm on ways to generate ideas. However, where the problem lies is that not everyone can brainstorm enough to create ideas, but they maraud around to still other people's ideas. Ideas are very expensive and if well-nurtured, they become a huge source of wealth, as a result, they should be protected as much as possible. Nicholai Tesla jumped to his death in sorrows. He made such a decision because Thomas Edison conned him, taking away his invention and getting the patent that should belong to Tesla. Nothing hurts more than seeing one's idea enrich another person while one wallows in abject poverty and dishonor. This is the reason one should follow the steps below on how to protect one's ideas. Don't Reveal too much of your Idea: The patent attorneys have warned most firm owners and starters to be wary of revealing too much about their firm to other people. This might sound difficult, especially when you need the help of people around you to win their conviction to assist you. But it is better to be patient than seeing your idea fatten an individual who will watch you die. Once you tell them little about it, they will help if they so wish. Use Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA): The problem about signing this with investors is that they leave you as soon as you reveal your intention on having an NDA signed. Best patent attorneys around the world have recommended that you sign a confidentiality document in print. This might be helpful if an investor doesn't want to sign an NDA with you. Patent your Ideas: Though a patent might be quite costly to come by, best patent attorneys have recommended provisional patent to startups. The provisional patent expires after twelve months and there is no way you can extend it, except you want to opt-in for a patent. While it might cost a lot of money to patent your idea, litigation is costly and you might not even end up winning. This is why most patent attorneys recommend that you patent to protect your idea. Do Necessary Research: Sometimes, it is necessary to go for relevant research before venturing into business with a contractor, a client or a potential investor. The best patent attorneys have advised that idea owners should seek information as regards investors' previous disputes with other business owners. Document Everything: While you might be eager to rush things or your investor might hurry you, you still have to ensure that you document detail and stage of your activities. This will provide you enough evidence whenever you need it. This is in line with the recommendations of most of the best patent attorneys, documentation is protection. Although it is cool to protect your idea, you don't have to be too overprotective. This consequence of overprotectiveness is that your idea might not worth a penny yet, but you would not know. It might only need a little suggestion from someone before it becomes the golden idea you wanted it to be. So it is good to apply your wit when matters of sharing or revealing your ideas come up. Read Also: Evolution Of The U.S. Patent System The Basics Of Criminal Appeals Law

READ MOREDetails
Divorce Decree

How to Get Copy of a Divorce Decree

A divorce decree is a document which is the most authentic proof of the fact that a couple that was previously married is now divorced.  Therefore, the couple must be mindful of keeping it safely post their divorce. Most divorce lawyers in Delhi would also advise their client to continue to have possession of the divorce decree even years after their divorce since it is not always possible to foresee the purposes for which that divorce decree might be needed in future. This blog shall aim to stress the importance of a divorce decree and acquaint our readers with the importance of keeping a divorce decree safe, even years after the divorce has been finalized. The reason why a divorce decree is so important is that it bears the official seal and stamp of the court’s officer or the court clerk. The decree duly delivered by a judicial magistrate is likely to contain, apart from the fact that the couple is divorced, also details pertaining to custody, alimony, visitation, maintenance, division of assets and liabilities, etc. Why a Divorce Decree is Important? Suppose that a divorced person wants to remarry. Before issuing him a marriage registration certificate, the first thing that the marriage registrar is going to ask for is a divorce decree relating to the previous marriage because, barring Mohammedan law, the personal laws of almost all other religions prohibit bigamy and polygamy. Another instance where a party may require a copy of a divorce decree is to ascertain their rights before the court if the other party/spouse defaults in performing his duties under the divorce decree. For instance, if the other spouse, denies the first spouse visitation rights to the child, or the other spouse defaults in payment of monthly maintenance or alimony to the first spouse, then, to be able to enforce these rights before a court of law, the aggrieved spouse shall definitely need a certified and true copy of the divorce decree. The divorce decree shall act as conclusive proof of the rights to which the aggrieved spouse is entitled to and therefore cannot be rebutted by any other evidence in a court law. The court will then, on seeing a copy of the divorce decree, prima facie hold the defaulting party in contempt of court. How can you get your Divorce Decree Made? For all the above-mentioned purposes, possession of a divorce decree is incumbent. If the person fails to possess one, he or she must apply to the court for obtaining a certified copy of the same. As a first step, what the party can do is to approach his or her lawyer, which he or she had hired for their divorce case. Lawyers usually maintain a record of documents of all their cases until a reasonable amount of time. This, they do because even they realize the importance of legal documents and in order to render to their client an enhanced service, they prefer keeping a file wise record of all the essential documents of all their cases. If the party had not hired a lawyer and had obtained their divorce on their own, or if their lawyers also do not have a copy of the same, the party will necessarily have to approach the court, which had granted them their divorce decree. Specific Details that a Divorce Decree needs to have For this purpose, the party will require knowledge of certain details, pertaining to the year of his or her divorce, the court, which granted the divorce, the name of the judge or bench, which granted the divorce, etc. These details will help the court clerk to easily access the case and find the divorce decree for that particular matter. Once the decree is found, all that the party has to do is to collect the said, certified and true copy of the divorce decree, paid the requisite fee to the concerned court clerk and then that copy of the divorce decree shall be duly handed over to the applicant party. However, notwithstanding the fact that the court clerk may obtain a copy of the divorce decree from the court clerk, there always exists the possibility that even the court loses track of such record and the copy of the divorce decree is not found in the court’s record even after an expansive search. It is therefore advisable that the parties themselves maintain a copy of such important legal document for as long as they live. Read Also: How To Bring Up Divorce With Your Spouse What Are The Grounds For Divorce In Illinois? Top 7 Reasons To Hire A Private Detective Agency During Divorce Cases

READ MOREDetails