When Restaurants Fight Back: A Diner’s Failed Attempt to Sue a Food Critic for Defamation

by

23 November 2024

Legal

food critic

Restaurant reviews can make or break your business.

A positive review of your restaurant can keep your cash counter busy and tables filled with loud and happy customers. But, a negative review does the complete opposite, leaving hardly any cash to collect and fewer tables to clean. 

Food critics hold power, and restaurants know it. Some establishments accept criticism and learn from it. Others take a more aggressive approach that can backfire badly.

This is what happened to a well-known diner when they decided to fight back against a food critic. The results were not what they expected.

The Case of Il Giardino

A Vancouver-based Italian restaurant, Il Giardino, was a local favorite. It’s known for its classic pasta dishes and cozy atmosphere. But in 2011, the restaurant’s reputation was challenged. The trouble began when a respected food critic, Colin Thomas, wrote a review that painted the restaurant in a negative light. He described the food as bland, overpriced, and lacking the warmth it once had.

The owners of Il Giardino were furious. They felt that Thomas’ words were not just harsh but unfair and damaging. They believed his review crossed the line and hurt their business. So, they decided to take legal action and sue him for defamation.

The Lawsuit That Backfired

The Lawsuit That Backfired

This lawsuit was something new and big news indeed. It’s not every day that you get to see a restaurant sue a critic.

Many people were curious about how it would turn out. The owners argued that the review was defamatory and claimed it had caused them to lose customers and money.

But fighting a food critic in court is tricky. Critics are protected under free speech laws. The court decided that Thomas’ review was an opinion, not a statement of fact. It didn’t meet the standard for defamation. The case was dismissed.

Instead of fixing their problem, Il Giardino made it worse. The lawsuit brought more attention to the bad review. News outlets covered the story, and people talked about it on social media. What might have been forgotten in a week was now in the spotlight for months. The restaurant’s online reputation suffered more than it did from the original review.

Why Suing Critics Is Risky

When a restaurant fights back, it backfires on them. And it’s not really a smart move to sue a food critic. Here’s why –

1. Freedom of Speech

Critics have the right to share their opinions. If a review is based on an experience and doesn’t include false claims, it is protected as free speech. Courts are careful about setting a precedent that could limit this freedom.

2. The Streisand Effect

Trying to silence a critic can lead to more attention. This is known as the Streisand Effect, named after Barbra Streisand, who tried to hide photos of her home but ended up drawing more attention to them. The same happened to Il Giardino. Their attempt to stop the review only made it more popular.

3. Public Backlash

People don’t like it when businesses try to suppress opinions. It can make a restaurant look like it can’t handle criticism or is trying to bully a writer. This can lead to backlash and damage a brand’s reputation.

Lessons Learned from the McDonald’s Case

Even major brands like McDonald’s have faced backlash for going after critics. In 1990, McDonald’s sued two environmental activists in the UK for distributing pamphlets that accused the company of poor practices. The case became known as the “McLibel” trial and lasted ten years.

The outcome? A PR disaster for McDonald’s. The activists couldn’t pay damages, but they won public support. McDonald’s spent millions on legal fees and looked like the villain. The company’s reputation took a hit, showing that even large corporations can face consequences when they overreact to criticism.

How to Handle Criticism as a Restaurant?

It’s not uncommon these days for a brand to get backlash from critics or customers. But how they handle it makes all the difference. Some of the tactics below work really well to handle criticism:

1. Respond Calmly and Professionally

A calm response can go a long way. Thank the critic for their feedback and mention any changes you plan to make. This shows that the restaurant values customer opinions and is willing to improve.

2. Focus on Positive Reviews

A bad review hurts, but it doesn’t define a restaurant. Focus on encouraging happy customers to leave positive reviews. A mix of reviews shows that a restaurant is real and popular. According to BrightLocal, 87% of consumers read online reviews for local businesses. A few negative reviews won’t hurt as much if there are plenty of positive ones.

3. Improve Feedback

Sometimes, criticism has truth in it. Look at what the critic pointed out and see if there are ways to improve. This can help turn a negative into a positive. It shows customers that the restaurant listens and evolves.

4. Invest in Online Reputation Management

If a bad review is causing ongoing issues, using an online reputation management service can help. These services can guide a restaurant on how to boost its online image and deal with negative press.

Recommendations for Restaurant Owners

Before your business has to handle something as harsh, it’s better to build some ground rules that keep your business away from such events. 

Think Before Reacting

It’s natural to feel upset after reading a harsh review, but it’s important to think before acting. Responding to anger or taking legal action can lead to bigger problems.

Provide Exceptional Customer Service

The foundation for a good business reputation starts with a business capability of delivering class-A customer service.

So, start by training your team. Warm and attentive staff attract more customers and build a good impression about your restaurant among clients. With open communication, your staff will take the business extra mile and exceed customer expectations. 

Communicate with Your Team

Make sure your team knows how to handle criticism. Training staff to respond professionally and with empathy can keep the restaurant’s image strong.

Don’t Compromise in the Food Quality

If the raw materials start to cost more, your customers may understand if the price goes high by a little. But, lowering food quality to adjust food prices can do damage to your restaurant in the long run. Always use fresh and high-quality ingredients to make food. Consistency in the quality of your food is the key to how you will succeed.

Stay Engaged with Customers

Interact with customers on review sites and social media. Show that you care about their experiences, good or bad. This connection can build loyalty and encourage repeat visits.

The Takeaway

Il Giardino’s attempt to sue a food critic for defamation is a reminder that fighting criticism can often make things worse. Publicly challenging a review can lead to more attention, public backlash, and damage to a business’s reputation.

Instead, restaurants should focus on learning from criticism and responding professionally. Encouraging positive feedback and engaging with customers can help maintain a strong image. And when extra help is needed, an online reputation management service can provide the right support.

In the end, handling criticism with grace and using it as a tool for improvement will benefit a restaurant far more than a court case ever could.

Read Also:

A passionate writer and an avid reader, Soumava is academically inclined and loves writing on topics requiring deep research. Having 3+ years of experience, Soumava also loves writing blogs in other domains, including digital marketing, business, technology, travel, and sports.

View all posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related

Divorce Lawyer

Things To Consider Before Hiring A Divorce Lawyer

Going through a divorce is already traumatic. Hiring a divorce lawyer shouldn’t be. You already have so much to think about. If you have children and combined assets, the process of divorce would become even more tangled. If your lawyer is good, you can avoid a long tussle and solve things fast so you can put the disturbing past behind you and move on. Hiring a lawyer is a very important task. Your future is at stake here. Your emotional and financial health is in your lawyer’s hands. The longer you have been in the marriage the more tangled the case becomes. If you have debts, dividing these could be tricky. There would be a lot of clauses that need to be looked into to divide these debts and assets. If you’re going through the divorce with a lawyer, chances are that your partner has a lawyer too. Since law proceedings can go any way, it is extremely important that you choose a lawyer that can help you get your fair share of the years and life that you built together with your partner. We can understand that the entire situation must be really overwhelming for you so we’ve put together a list of the top factors that you need to consider while hiring a lawyer. Things To Consider Before Hiring A Divorce Lawyer: Attorney’s experience: It goes without saying that your attorney must have experience with divorce proceedings. Law is a tricky boat to steer and unless your lawyer has some experience he would not be aware of the obstacles he needs to steer past. Now even while looking for a lawyer, check their credentials and certifications. You could personally check up with these some of the people they’ve worked with in the past. It would give you a fair idea of how the lawyer works. The biggest thing that you’d find out is their credibility. It is important that you go through many of their previous clients to make an informed decision. Fred Coover of Coover Law advises considering the experience and local reputation of a divorce lawyer before hiring them. Any big decision needs groundwork. Put in some time and effort to browse through the lawyer directory in your area and sift through their cases. Everything is available online, so you could do this any time. Lawyers generally have multiple cases in different branches that they work in their careers. Choose a lawyer that has experience in specifically divorce cases. This would tell you that they know their way around divorce proceedings. Background check: After checking their experience, check up on the lawyer’s background and how credible they are. If they have a reputation of unscrupulous methods of filing and fighting cases, you may want to steer clear. You don’t want to be stuck with a lawyer who doesn’t do things ethically because this could put your case in jeopardy as well. Divorce proceedings should be a one-time thing. You don’t want to go through the mental trauma again. If your lawyer employs unscrupulous methods, the case could be open again and you may have to compensate more than you received in the divorce hearing. Contact the local bar council and find out about the lawyer you’re thinking of hiring. They would be in the best position to advise you and give you information about the lawyer you’re seeking. Communication: Since filing cases is all about communication, when you meet the lawyer, you must be able to communicate with them effectively. Everyone’s way of communication is different and you must find one for yourself with whom you can communicate. If you feel like the lawyer isn’t true to what they say, move on to the next. Most lawyers who have been in practice for a long time have a fixed way of working and you shouldn’t have problems. In case you do, move on to find another attorney. They must be available for you via calls, emails or be open to meeting in person in their work hours. This shows that the lawyer is committed to your case. As Jim Parke from leading Melbourne law firm tells us, “Divorce is a very emotional and stressful time for the parties involved. It’s important to hire a lawyer who is sympathetic and understanding but also acts swiftly so things can be done in a timely manner”. The last thing you want is a drawn-out process which makes the event even harder to deal with. His legal practice ensures divorce proceedings are taken care of quickly. Fees of the attorney: While hiring a lawyer, inquire about their fees. Some lawyers charge by the hour and some for consultation. The normal rate that most experienced divorce lawyers charge is anywhere between $100 to $200 for consultation. Clear the paperwork and discuss the mode of payment clearly with them. Are the payments properly invoiced? Will any fees be refunded if you don’t employ their services. Lawyers charge a retainer fee which is an upfront fee. Check with the lawyer if this fees will be refunded in case you decide to terminate the contract midway. Ensure that the contract mentions all these terms clearly before signing. Read Also: How To Get A Cheap Divorce In Texas What Are The Grounds For Divorce In Illinois? How Long Does It Take To Get A Divorce In The UK? 3 Reasons Why You Might Need A Family Lawyer Top 7 Reasons To Hire A Private Detective Agency During Divorce Cases 6 Ways To Heal After Divorce From An Emotionally Abusive Marriage Top 7 Reasons To Hire A Private Detective Agency During Divorce Cases Divorce Lawyers In Houston Texas: A Short Guide On Saving Your Marriage

READ MOREDetails
Divorce Lawyers In Houston Texas:Guide On Saving Your Marriage

Divorce Lawyers In Houston Texas:Guide On Saving Your Marriage

Most couples who start the divorce process are not prepared and frequently are not the same page.  This lack of readiness and preparedness for a divorce can either cause a divorce to deteriorate into a competitive right or cause a premature end to a marriage.  The decision to get a divorce is among the most critical decisions that an individual can make, and the consequences can last a lifetime or at least for many years.  This is a very important decision that requires more attention than is usual for both the professional divorce lawyers in Houston Texas and the couple.  It is its own unique process. After a couple has prepared and is ready to go, they will be able to start on the divorce with both parties being on the same page.  That can help to eliminate the majority of the financial and emotional struggles that can cause a divorce to become ruthless and adversarial. The key is time : If you are considering leaving your spouse, think about the amount of time you spend together.  It is critical in 2018 to make it a priority to make date night appointments, and to do things as a couple on a consistent basis, even if it's just having a cup of coffee in the morning at home or exercising together. Encourage each other : At times we might forget to give our partners encouragement, especially during stressful times.  When a crisis occurs, be there for one another.  Give advice and cheer on your partner.  Remind them of past situations that the two of you had to overcome. Learn how to deal with conflict : Every couple argues.  However, there is a right and wrong way to go about this.  It is normal and natural but avoids blaming and name-calling. If you are often stubborn and have a hard time admitting you are wrong, then work on those traits and how to make compromises with your spouse.  Be willing to offer and ask for forgiveness and apologize. Don't take your spouse for granted & Be your best self : When individuals get into a relationship, they often feel they don't need to worry anymore about impressing their spouse and then later, they forget to focus on things such as their appearance or health. Give small gifts : We really do mean small. Get your partner a small gift or leave a romantic note before heading to work.  A small gesture can help to keep that spark alive and demonstrate that you care about them. Accept your differences Whenever a couple of fight, each one expects their partner to be the one that has to change.  However, to the relationship to work, it is important to accept the fact that you can't make people change, and that differences are often a good thing. The reason that so many people don't consider preparing for a divorce is that they assume that the sooner they can get away from a stressful situation that the better off they will be.  It is natural for individuals who are part of a difficult marriage to hope their divorce can be finalized as soon as possible so that they can get on with life.  This is also often encouraged by friends and family.  They feel hurt for their family member and believe in the myth that the faster the divorce can be completed, the sooner that everything can go back to normal. In most cases, however, the opposite occurs.  Couples who rush into leaving their marriages don't have any time to really evaluate their options, thoughts, or feelings.  This results in them being unprepared for the complex legal system, roller coaster of all their emotions, and all the life-changing decisions that must be made.  Frequently they end up making agreements that are unsustainable, and rather than the situation improving, they frequently discover that all they have done is swapped one set of issues for another set. That is why it isn't surprising that they frequently end up in long court cases, and it often takes years to get through the divorce process instead of ending it quickly as they had hoped for. Read Also : Fundaments Of Happy Family 4 Tips For Dealing With A Family Business In Divorce 5 Ways To Save Money On Your Wedding Invites

READ MOREDetails
Legal Case

Legal Case Preparation – What You Can Do

No one ever expects to be faced with a legal case, but if it happens, you'll want to be as prepared as possible. This article will give you some tips on how to get ready for a legal battle, so that you can come out on top. Whether you're a business or an individual in Thailand or anywhere else in the world, these tips will help you protect your interests. Read on to learn more! 1. Speak with an experienced lawyer to get a better understanding of your case and the possible outcomes If you are pursuing a lawsuit or have to be a defendant in a lawsuit, the most important thing you can do to prepare for a legal case is to understand the legal process and how it works. You may be involved in a lawsuit for personal reasons, but you should know what you should expect from your attorney and the court. An attorney will be able to explain the process in more detail and will be able to explain what you can expect from the court process. Your attorney will also help you prepare for the depositions and trial. 2. Gather all the evidence you have that supports your case It’s essential to be prepared to present evidence in court. Using the discovery process to get information is a good idea as well. Using the right tools and resources can make all the difference in your case. 3. Cooperate with your lawyer and provide them with any information they need You need to know how to respond to the case and prepare yourself for a court hearing. After all, you want to feel confident in your own words, but it's also necessary that you listen to your lawyer. A good case starts with a well-drafted pleading. A law firm in Bangkok, for example, can provide you with an attorney who can best help you understand your rights in Thailand and provide an excellent legal strategy. Be sure to communicate with your lawyer throughout the process. Remember to be truthful with your lawyer and don't be afraid to share sensitive information. Having the right documents and evidence can help you win your case. Your attorney will be your representative in the courtroom. A good lawyer will listen to you and make suggestions that are relevant to your case. If your legal matter is complicated, your lawyer will be able to answer all your questions and protect your interests. If you have any doubts, do not hesitate to ask your lawyer questions. You should also make sure your lawyer knows how to handle your particular case. 4. Don't speak to anyone about your case other than your lawyer It is essential to avoid discussing your legal matter with anyone, including your family, before or during your trial. Only your attorney or your legal representative should know about the details of your case. Your lawyer can use any conversation to help your defense, so do not make false statements. Also, do not make any comments that could be used against you if your case is a civil suit. 5. Stay calm and don't let the situation overwhelm you During the trial, you will need to prepare yourself for questions and to give a good presentation. Be prepared to answer questions and to make brief notes of important points. The judge isn't interested in lengthy testimony and irrelevant arguments. Rather, a short, well-written statement about your case goals will be appreciated by the judge. If you prepare yourself well, your lawyer will have a better chance of winning your case. Expect the other party’s lawyer to be intimidating, but with proper preparation, the process is easier. With a good lawyer on your side, you’ll be able to find the best solution for your legal problem. It is important to know the law so you can choose the best attorney, one who can communicate effectively with you. There are many law firms that post their lawyers' resumes online. You should read these resumes carefully and choose one. Read Also: An Introduction to Long-Term Disability Claims Steps to Filing a Car Accident Claim in Waukegan Filing a Personal Injury Claim in Chicago What Are the Common Causes of Catastrophic Injuries?

READ MOREDetails