How Do Self-Driving Cars Really Compare To Human Drivers

Published on: 25 March 2018 Last Updated on: 24 February 2020
Do Self-Driving Cars

Although a lot of comparisons have been made between self-driving vehicles and human drivers, not all of those comparisons have been fair or accurate.

One study found that distracted driving accounted for approximately 4 million accidents each year. That is almost half of the 11 million crashes that take place on an annual basis. Unfortunately, the problem only seems to be getting worse as distractions like texting become more and more common. Researchers recently analyzed a group of 28 studies, comparing the data. According to their findings, texting or looking at a phone while driving can have numerous adverse effects, ranging from limiting the ability of the driver to detect stimuli, to decreasing reaction times, causing a loss of control over the vehicle, and increasing the rate of collisions.

Based on this information, some researchers even believe that texting while driving is more dangerous than operating a vehicle at the legal limit for alcohol or while under the influence of marijuana. The problem isn’t only limited to teenagers. Older adults are every bit as likely to be guilty of texting while driving. They are also far more likely to talk on their phones while driving.

One of the primary arguments used by proponents of self-driving cars is that they eliminate distracted driving. This, in turn, could possibly decrease the number of crashes, limiting the number of deaths and injuries that occur on an annual basis. In actuality, however, comparisons between self-driving vehicles in human drivers don’t necessarily bear that out.

According to studies, over 90% of the automobile accidents that occur in the United States are caused by driver error. In theory, stopping these accidents could reduce the new for the Trevino Law Firm in Corpus Christi, but also, save the lives of the same number of people as were killed in Vietnam within just two years of the technology being introduced.

As someone who researches human factors, I don’t find that information adequate for evaluating whether or not automated vehicles would be better at avoiding crashes than humans. The only way to tell for sure is by evaluating how many times drivers avoid collisions. What are the actual odds of getting in a collision for a human driver?

Of course, this is extremely hard to measure. For instance, say that you were trying to determine how many times you avoided bumping into people in the hall. To figure that out, you need to not only look at the amount of time that you spent walking down the hallway but also the number of people that were present. When a non-event occurs, it is usually overlooked or easily forgotten. However, to make a fair comparison between self-driving vehicles and human drivers, researchers need to gather statistics about the number of non-collisions that occur in both situations.

Comparing Statistics Equally

Accident statistics relating to human drivers are drawn from a number of different driving conditions. For instance, some statistics come from people driving when it is raining out while others come from people driving on dirt roads. The bulk of the data on self-driving vehicles, on the other hand, has been gathered from states in the western part of the country. Typically, these cars are only analyzed when the weather is good. The data itself is primarily recorded when the vehicles are driving on highways with multiple lanes in a single direction. In these types of situations, the primary tasks that the car has to accomplish include staying in its own lane and avoiding tailgating the vehicle in front of it.

These types of tasks are relatively easy for automated vehicles. Of course, humans are also quite good at accomplishing these tasks. Until more data is gathered from other parts of the country and on different types of roads, however, it is difficult to make a fair comparison. In fact, it will most likely be a long time before a self-driving vehicle has the opportunity to drive as many miles on an annual basis as a typical human driver.

One of the advantages of automated vehicles is that they don’t succumb to human problems such as tiredness, anger, or drunkenness. At the same time, however, they lack the reasoning skills to deal with unexpected or confusing situations. They also can’t really anticipate potentially dangerous situations that may be coming further down the road as a human driver could. Instead, they operate at the moment.

Automated systems have a hard time distinguishing between different types of objects. A group of people waiting at a bus stop might look almost the same as an empty cornfield. If a vehicle is facing an emergency situation, most drivers take the course of action that will minimize damage to both themselves and the people around them. A self-driving vehicle doesn’t have the ability to analyze the situation and decide on the best course of action. Instead, they only react in one way, which may not necessarily be the best way.

Technological Advancements Create Fresh Complications

Most people are on board with the idea of pursuing driverless technology, simply because there is the potential for it to reduce the number of accidents that occur. It would be amazing if these vehicles were able to stop car accidents altogether, eliminating deaths and injuries on the road. Of course, some people love getting behind the wheel and driving their vehicles. In that case, they may feel disappointed not to be able to drive their car.

Of course, the new technology doesn’t always result in better outcomes. All that you have to do is look at the aviation industry for examples. When new technology is introduced, the number of negative events usually increases temporarily. This may discourage people from fully embracing self-driving technology if this also occurs with automated vehicles.

When comparing human drivers and self-driving vehicles, it is important to use caution. It is going to be a long time before all of the cars on the road are replaced by automated vehicles. In the meantime, self-driving cars and human drivers will have to interact with one another. How this will play out remains to be seen.

If you want to honestly compare driverless technology and human drivers, you need to make sure that those comparisons are being made accurately and under the same circumstances. Comparing two different sets of data from different driving conditions won’t give an accurate picture of how the technology performs in comparison to traditional vehicles. As with any major technological shift, it is important to proceed slowly and to use caution to avoid unexpected problems along the way.

 

Content Rally wrapped around an online publication where you can publish your own intellectuals. It is a publishing platform designed to make great stories by content creators. This is your era, your place to be online. So come forward share your views, thoughts and ideas via Content Rally.

View all posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related

Car Battery Maintenance

Car Battery Maintenance 101

Here’s a fact to get the ball rolling; Did you know? Majority of car breakdowns are due to a simple battery failure. Car Battery Maintenance can reduce the chances of your car breaking down. That’s right! Batteries, an invention of the 1800s still very much useful today. Power windows, music system, headlights, auxiliaries and what not, car batteries are an essential part of an automobile. A car battery has a limited lifespan, a well-maintained car battery should last you around 3-5 years, But many find that they have to replace their car battery every 1 to 2 years. A poorly maintained battery loses its capacity to hold a charge and eventually fails. So, if you want to avoid the inconvenience of an unexpected breakdown simultaneously ensuring a prolonged battery life, we are here with 5 simple tips on car battery maintenance. 1. Always keep the battery terminals corrosion-free: One of the most recurrent problems with battery is corrosion build-up on the negative and positive terminals. Corrosion acts as a barrier between the battery and the vehicle thereby breaking the connection. A simple fix for this can be a light scrubbing with an abrasive pad to dislodge the crud build-up from the terminals. Car battery maintenance can minimize the chances of corrosion. Top Tip: add a dab of vaseline to the terminals to prevent further corrosion 2. Do not operate any electronics during startup: When the engine is running,  the car alternator generates electricity and charges the car battery, but when the engine is off, the car relies on battery power only. So, it is important to limit the use of any electronics just before or while starting the car to avoid unnecessary load on the battery. Top Tip: switch off the AC and the music system before cranking the car to avoid damage to the battery. 3. Full charge your car battery at least once every month: Did you know? Your car draws power from the battery even when the car is off. This is required for the anti-theft system to function. Make a habit of charging your car battery every month or two to avoid a dead battery situation. This will also help the battery maintain a healthy charge density and prolong its life. Invest in a good battery charger for your vehicle if you don't wish to visit a garage every month. 4. Check your car’s alternator for car battery maintenance: An Alternator is a very crucial component responsible for charging the car battery when the engine is running. So, it becomes very important to ensure a functional alternator for a healthy battery life. Get the alternator checked every time you visit a garage. Telltale signs of a failing alternator include; battery warning light on the dashboard, flickering headlights, engine cranking issues, and other electronic failures. 5. Do not overload your car battery with accessories: Auxiliary fog lamps, high power music system, novelty lighting. These are all power hungry accessories draining the life out of your car battery. Every car battery has a load limit and can take only much before failing. Car battery maintenance can make your car move faster. So, go easy with those fancy lights you’ve just bought off Amazon, and check if your battery is capable of taking the increased loads. Bonus Tip: Always top-up car battery with distilled water ONLY: In this day and age of “No-Maintenance” batteries, you don’t have to periodically refill the batteries with water anymore. But still, all car batteries require a specific level of distilled water to function optimally. Distilled water is required for the proper flow of electricity in the battery. Using normal tap water which contains metal ions can permanently damage the electrodes causing a degradation in charging capacity of a battery. Low water level can damage the cells inside the battery causing a failure. Visit your nearest hardware store for a litre of distilled battery water. Read Also: Car Insurance For Electric Vehicles Explained Important Tips To Maintain Your Luxury Car

READ MOREDetails
Does Elon Musk Have In His Vehicle Fleet

What Does Elon Musk Have In His Vehicle Fleet?

As we know, Elon Musk, the enigmatic entrepreneur and visionary behind companies such as Tesla, SpaceX, and Neuralink, is famous for his relentless pursuit of innovation, which enables him to push the boundaries of technology. As an extraordinary individual and one of the most influential figures in business, it's natural to wonder which vehicle models Elon Musk prefers to drive. Does he prioritize practicality or luxury? Let's take a peek inside the businessman's garage and explore the fascinating vehicles that he chooses to drive. Tesla Roadster Let's start with the incredible Tesla Roadster, a true technological and design marvel. This model is the first all-electric sports car to hit the road. So, it's not a surprise that Elon drives this vehicle often. The Roadster's specs also deserve special attention. While the first version of this electric sports car was released in 2008, the most recent configuration, released in 2022, is truly an engineering masterpiece in the automotive world. Along with a sleek design that makes this vehicle a stunning embodiment of elegance on wheels, it also has an astonishing acceleration time of 1.9 seconds from 0 to 100 km/h (0-60 mph)! The electric motor produces 10,000 Nm of torque, allowing for a top speed of more than 250 mph (400 km/h). What truly distinguishes the Roadster is its incredible range, reaching up to over 620 miles (1,000 km) on a single charge. Porsche 911 Beyond his electric vehicle ventures, Elon Musk has also been spotted driving a Porsche 911, a legendary sports car known for its timeless design and exhilarating performance. This vehicle delivers an exceptional driving experience with its impressive specifications and features. Boasting a timeless design, the 911 combines elegance and aerodynamic efficiency. Under the hood, it offers a variety of powerful engines, ranging from the 3.0L option with up to 450 hp to the 4.0L motor with 520 hp. The Porsche 911 stands as a symbol of automotive excellence, combining timeless design, powerful performance, advanced technology, and a luxurious driving experience. This car continues to captivate enthusiasts and embody the spirit of Porsche's dedication to engineering mastery. Tesla Model X Here we have one of the world's first electric crossovers that combines both sporty performance and family comfort. If we speak about Elon's automotive fleet, the businessman owns the 2016 Model X configuration. In addition, the vehicle can carry up to seven passengers. With its unique and luxurious interior, the Model X immediately became the star of car shows and exhibitions. The Model X is capable of covering up to 300 miles (475 km) on a single charge and reaching speeds of up to 60 mph (100 km/h) in 2.7 seconds. The car received five stars in the NHTSA safety rating, becoming the first with such ratings in the SUV class. Tesla Model S Performance The Model S Performance takes the combination of convenience, power, and efficiency to new heights, setting remarkable standards for electric vehicles. With its astounding acceleration capabilities, this car can reach speeds of up to 60 mph (100 km/h) in less than 2.5 seconds, providing an exhilarating driving experience. Furthermore, it offers an impressive range of up to 400 miles (652 km) on a single charge, ensuring long-distance journeys without the need for frequent recharging. This Tesla EV goes beyond its exceptional performance by prioritizing passenger comfort and versatility. Inside its cabin, this vehicle comfortably accommodates five adult passengers and two children, making it an ideal choice for families or group travel. The addition of an all-wheel-drive system further enhances its capabilities, allowing you to confidently conquer any road condition, be it slippery surfaces or challenging terrain. The Model S Performance truly embodies the perfect balance of speed and adaptability, leveling up what electric vehicles can offer. Lotus Esprit Perhaps the most intriguing addition to Elon Musk's garage is the famous Lotus Esprit submarine car from the James Bond film “The Spy Who Loved Me.” Musk, an avid James Bond fan, purchased the iconic vehicle in 2013. While it may not be for a daily drive, it reflects Musk's adventurous side. The legendary Lotus Esprit, produced by British manufacturer Lotus Cars, showcases a combination of sleek design, exhilarating performance, and agile handling. Its distinctive appearance sets the vehicle apart from other sports cars, featuring a low-slung profile and aerodynamic body lines that convey a sense of speed even at a standstill. Under the hood, the Lotus Esprit offers a range of powerful engines that deliver impressive performance. From turbocharged four-cylinder engines to V8 motors, the Esprit provides great acceleration and a fantastic driving experience. The interior of the Lotus Esprit is focused on the driver, providing a cockpit-like environment with supportive seats, intuitive controls, and clear visibility. Despite its sports car nature, the Esprit offers a level of comfort and refinement that allows for enjoyable long-distance driving. Tesla Cybertruck Let's now turn our attention to the most unusual vehicle in Elon's garage, the 2020 Tesla Cybertruck. This vehicle appears to have arrived from the future to demonstrate that technological possibilities are limitless. The Tesla Cybertruck is a cutting-edge all-electric pickup truck that challenges conventional automotive design. Its body is made of ultra-hard 30X cold-rolled stainless steel, which guarantees exceptional durability and resistance to any damage. The Cybertruck has an impressive performance, with 0-60 mph (0-100 km/h) acceleration in as little as 2.9 seconds and a towing capacity of up to 14,000 pounds (6.35 t). The Cybertruck's spacious interior can seat up to six passengers and is outfitted with cutting-edge technology and luxurious touches. The Tesla Cybertruck is set to revolutionize the pickup truck industry with its cutting-edge design, robust capabilities, and commitment to sustainability. Summing Up Elon Musk's garage showcases his passion for cutting-edge technology, sustainability, and automotive excellence. His automotive preferences, including his own creations at Tesla, classic sports cars, and even a famous movie prop, reflect his diverse interests and vision for the future. Through his innovative electric vehicle ventures, Musk hasn't only pushed the automotive industry forward but also inspired a global shift toward sustainable transportation. Read Also: Why You Need Classic Car Insurance? 7 Reasons Why Teenagers Pay Extra For Car Insurance

READ MOREDetails
Used Car

Used Car Buying – How To Do It Right.

Used cars tend to be the most popular amongst UK drivers and it can be easy to see why. Second-hand cars have a lower purchase price, suffer from less depreciation and there is an endless amount of choice! The main disadvantage of buying a used car is the lack of knowledge regarding its history. When you buy a new car, you will be the first owner and don’t have to second guess how the car’s been treated or if it’s been involved in an accident. Reduce the risk of something going wrong with your next used car purchase by following these top tips below for safe car buying.  Know your affordability.  Before you make any large purchase, you should know how much you can afford to pay for it. This can speed up the buying process if you only shop for cars within your budget. Your budget may be one lump sum to pay for a car with cash or spread the cost into monthly payments with finance. Whichever way you choose to buy your next used car, you should try not to stray from your budget as you may get into a deal that you can’t afford to pay back. Check the market value.  Once you know how much you can spend on a used car, it’s time to see which cars you could buy. A quick internet search of local, trusted dealerships can help you to find used cars you can afford. It also gives you an idea of how much the cars you like would cost. For example, if you’re striving for a used BMW on finance, knowing how much it would cost to buy one can give you an idea of how much your monthly budget could be. Knowing the market value of the cars you want to buy also helps if you’re buying with cash and wanting to negotiate the price. If there’s a similar model from a dealer down the road but with a lower price, you could use this as leverage or get a better deal.  Check credit score for finance. No matter if you’re looking for finance for a Volkswagen or a Porsche, the first thing you should do is to check your credit score. Your credit score can affect your ability to get approved for finance and not knowing where you fall on the credit scale can be costly. A low credit score can make it harder to get approved if your low score is due to missed or late payments in the past or a lack of credit history. This is because you are seen as more of a risk to lenders and are more likely to default on future loans too. If you need to improve your credit score you should do so before applying for finance.  Check insurance rates. If you’re buying your first car, insurance rates can be some of the highest around. Newly qualified drivers are more likely to have a road accident in their first year of driving which bumps up the premium. Searching around for cheaper cars to insure and in your budget could help you save money. buying a used car isn’t just about the initial purchase price but also about being able to afford the running cost too.  Use a reputable dealership.  You can buy a second-hand car from a dealer or private seller but to help protect your purchase, you should consider buying your car from a reputable and trusted dealer in the UK. Buying from a dealer gives you an added layer of protection and means you are covered by the Consumer Rights Act 2015. This act means you are entitled to a full refund, repair, or replacement if the car is not as described or fit for purpose. Check the status of the dealer with the FCA and read verified reviews of other customers before committing to the sale.  Check the history of the car. Used cars run the risk of having a hidden history but you can check the history of a car you are interested in buying for free. You can check the tax and MOT status of a car and get more information by simply entering the registration number into the DVLA website. You can also make a one-off payment of around £10 with a trusted Car History Check website to see if the car has been stolen, previously written off or still has existing finance on it.  Test drive and check the vehicle.  Before you commit to buying a used car, you should always test drive it first to see how you like it. Take the car out for at least 30 minutes, drive it on different types of roads, and perform maneuvers to get a feel of how it drives. Also, take this opportunity to park up somewhere and check over the vehicle for any imperfections or damage.  Read Also: Beginners Guide To Buying A Classic Car Buying a Used Car? Few Negotiating tips, you can use Used car: simple steps for buying from a reliable cars dealership

READ MOREDetails