How Do Self-Driving Cars Really Compare To Human Drivers

Published on: 25 March 2018 Last Updated on: 24 February 2020
Do Self-Driving Cars

Although a lot of comparisons have been made between self-driving vehicles and human drivers, not all of those comparisons have been fair or accurate.

One study found that distracted driving accounted for approximately 4 million accidents each year. That is almost half of the 11 million crashes that take place on an annual basis. Unfortunately, the problem only seems to be getting worse as distractions like texting become more and more common. Researchers recently analyzed a group of 28 studies, comparing the data. According to their findings, texting or looking at a phone while driving can have numerous adverse effects, ranging from limiting the ability of the driver to detect stimuli, to decreasing reaction times, causing a loss of control over the vehicle, and increasing the rate of collisions.

Based on this information, some researchers even believe that texting while driving is more dangerous than operating a vehicle at the legal limit for alcohol or while under the influence of marijuana. The problem isn’t only limited to teenagers. Older adults are every bit as likely to be guilty of texting while driving. They are also far more likely to talk on their phones while driving.

One of the primary arguments used by proponents of self-driving cars is that they eliminate distracted driving. This, in turn, could possibly decrease the number of crashes, limiting the number of deaths and injuries that occur on an annual basis. In actuality, however, comparisons between self-driving vehicles in human drivers don’t necessarily bear that out.

According to studies, over 90% of the automobile accidents that occur in the United States are caused by driver error. In theory, stopping these accidents could reduce the new for the Trevino Law Firm in Corpus Christi, but also, save the lives of the same number of people as were killed in Vietnam within just two years of the technology being introduced.

As someone who researches human factors, I don’t find that information adequate for evaluating whether or not automated vehicles would be better at avoiding crashes than humans. The only way to tell for sure is by evaluating how many times drivers avoid collisions. What are the actual odds of getting in a collision for a human driver?

Of course, this is extremely hard to measure. For instance, say that you were trying to determine how many times you avoided bumping into people in the hall. To figure that out, you need to not only look at the amount of time that you spent walking down the hallway but also the number of people that were present. When a non-event occurs, it is usually overlooked or easily forgotten. However, to make a fair comparison between self-driving vehicles and human drivers, researchers need to gather statistics about the number of non-collisions that occur in both situations.

Comparing Statistics Equally

Accident statistics relating to human drivers are drawn from a number of different driving conditions. For instance, some statistics come from people driving when it is raining out while others come from people driving on dirt roads. The bulk of the data on self-driving vehicles, on the other hand, has been gathered from states in the western part of the country. Typically, these cars are only analyzed when the weather is good. The data itself is primarily recorded when the vehicles are driving on highways with multiple lanes in a single direction. In these types of situations, the primary tasks that the car has to accomplish include staying in its own lane and avoiding tailgating the vehicle in front of it.

These types of tasks are relatively easy for automated vehicles. Of course, humans are also quite good at accomplishing these tasks. Until more data is gathered from other parts of the country and on different types of roads, however, it is difficult to make a fair comparison. In fact, it will most likely be a long time before a self-driving vehicle has the opportunity to drive as many miles on an annual basis as a typical human driver.

One of the advantages of automated vehicles is that they don’t succumb to human problems such as tiredness, anger, or drunkenness. At the same time, however, they lack the reasoning skills to deal with unexpected or confusing situations. They also can’t really anticipate potentially dangerous situations that may be coming further down the road as a human driver could. Instead, they operate at the moment.

Automated systems have a hard time distinguishing between different types of objects. A group of people waiting at a bus stop might look almost the same as an empty cornfield. If a vehicle is facing an emergency situation, most drivers take the course of action that will minimize damage to both themselves and the people around them. A self-driving vehicle doesn’t have the ability to analyze the situation and decide on the best course of action. Instead, they only react in one way, which may not necessarily be the best way.

Technological Advancements Create Fresh Complications

Most people are on board with the idea of pursuing driverless technology, simply because there is the potential for it to reduce the number of accidents that occur. It would be amazing if these vehicles were able to stop car accidents altogether, eliminating deaths and injuries on the road. Of course, some people love getting behind the wheel and driving their vehicles. In that case, they may feel disappointed not to be able to drive their car.

Of course, the new technology doesn’t always result in better outcomes. All that you have to do is look at the aviation industry for examples. When new technology is introduced, the number of negative events usually increases temporarily. This may discourage people from fully embracing self-driving technology if this also occurs with automated vehicles.

When comparing human drivers and self-driving vehicles, it is important to use caution. It is going to be a long time before all of the cars on the road are replaced by automated vehicles. In the meantime, self-driving cars and human drivers will have to interact with one another. How this will play out remains to be seen.

If you want to honestly compare driverless technology and human drivers, you need to make sure that those comparisons are being made accurately and under the same circumstances. Comparing two different sets of data from different driving conditions won’t give an accurate picture of how the technology performs in comparison to traditional vehicles. As with any major technological shift, it is important to proceed slowly and to use caution to avoid unexpected problems along the way.

 

Content Rally wrapped around an online publication where you can publish your own intellectuals. It is a publishing platform designed to make great stories by content creators. This is your era, your place to be online. So come forward share your views, thoughts and ideas via Content Rally.

View all posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related

Towing Mirrors

Towing Mirrors: Everything You Need To Know Right Now

The final destination movie series taught us one thing and that is to steer very clear of big trucks. Can’t say we blame you when you see a trailer truck on the road and change lanes. After all, trailer trucks are very difficult to drive and very vulnerable to road accidents. Most of the time, the trailer truck driver is unable to see obstacles or cars on the road due to the long length of the truck. This is one of the biggest reasons why there are so many truck accidents nowadays. The major reasons are improper cargo loading, drunk driving, mechanical issues, and visibility issues. Here, we will talk about visibility issues and how it contributes to unfortunate trailer truck accidents. What Role Does Improper Visibility Play In Trailer Truck Accidents? When your trailer or towing truck has some additional weight or cargo loaded on the back, it becomes very difficult to have complete visibility of the traffic behind. Moreover, standard mirrors do not have the ability to provide a full vision of the load on your truck and the traffic behind the load. Hence, this blocked visibility is what causes numerous road accidents. Blind spots play a major role in road hazards especially when it comes to trailer trucks and towing. In fact, blind sports are the major reason why towing-related casualties occur. You need to have full and good peripheral vision. However, this carelessness and disregard for safety and proper vision is the reason why truck road accidents have seen a hike of 52% since 2009. Out of this, 74% of these truck accidents involve big trucks such as trailer trucks. But, how do we avoid this? We can’t decrease the length of the trailer truck and we certainly can not use the truck for loading cargo. Then, what is a viable solution? The Solution; Towing Mirrors What are towing mirrors? Towing mirrors are extendable and attachable rearview mirrors. These mirrors have many features, the most important one being the adjustable length and height of towing mirrors. Towing mirrors are not just limited to towing truck use, they can be used for trucks with big trailer tails. So, if you want to avoid tow truck and trailer truck-related accidents, you must get towing mirrors for your truck. Personally, we have seen many satisfied customers of Holden Colorado Towing Mirrors. If you wish to avoid accidents and mishaps, opt for Holden Colorado to get the best towing mirrors. Trust me, you will not be disappointed and you will definitely understand how important they are. Towing mirrors are so important that in most states, the use of a towing mirror that provides a 200 feet view has become law. For example, in the United States, you are required by law to have a set of towing mirrors that allow a rearview of 200 feet. This law was passed when trail trucks and tow trucks related accidents and casualties started seeing a spike. A twenty meters view is required from the driver's position, as stated by the law. What Are The Benefits Of Towing Mirrors? Towing mirrors are the best solution for you if your trailer truck or tow truck does not have a good enough standard rearview mirror. And let's be honest, most of the trucks do not have a satisfactory rearview vision. In shorter and easier-to-understand words, here are some major benefits of towing mirrors. 1. Extended visibility The first and most important benefit of a towing mirror is the extended vision. When your vehicle has another vehicle or trailer hitched on the back, it will become very difficult to have proper vision. Towing mirrors provide a full and wide peripheral vision. 2. Safety The normalization of towing mirrors in tow trucks is a major contributing factor to why towing-related accident rates have started going down. With a wide visibility system installed in big trucks and tow trucks, blind spots are avoided and hence, ensure the safety of not just the driver but also the other drivers in the traffic. Towing mirrors ensures safe driving and there is nothing more important than the safety of human lives. 3. Automatic Heat function In winters, fog assembles and collects on these extendable mirrors. This is very common in cool areas where there is a lot of snowfall as well. It is not feasible or convenient to manually wipe rearview mirrors, let alone towing mirrors. This is because towing mirrors are extended to a height where you will have a lot of trouble extending your arm. Lucky for us, most towing mirrors have an automatic heating function feature. This system clears up the fog gathered on the mirrors automatically. Worry less! 4. Adjustable Another great feature of towing mirrors is that they are adjustable. Other than height control, towing mirrors have detaching features too. Most caravanners have this question, “do we have to remove the mirror once unhitched?” The answer is yes. As regulated by law, no obstacle or object is allowed to protrude 150 mm from the sides of the vehicle. Hence, it is important that you detach your towing mirrors when not in use to avoid hefty fines. Luckily, towing mirrors are detachable and you can easily install and reinstall them. 5. Blind spot display system The recent and newer models of towing mirrors have a camera under the towing mirror. This camera further enhances the vision of the road and the load attached to your vehicle and makes blind spots very visible to you, even at night. This is called the blind spot display system.  The camera image is displayed on the screen of the center console. 6. Legal requirement Lastly, as we have discussed before that many states have made it compulsory to have a towing mirror installed in your tow truck or trailer. If you are seen violating these laws, you will be fined heavily. Each mirror infringement gives you a £1,000 fine. However, it is important to note that you are only legally restricted to use towing mirrors when there is a load hitched to your vehicle. If you keep towing mirrors on otherwise, you will be violating other traffic laws. Additionals: Mirrors For Sale – Finding a Perfect Home Decorative ItemHow Activity Mirrors Add Value to Exercise Place!Mirror Decorating Ideas To Style Your Bathroom

READ MOREDetails
Truck Clean

Keeping The Truck Clean After Off-Roading Trip – Effective Tips

Off-roading can make your truck extremely dirty. You might see mud, dirt, and small rocks stuck in different places. Cleaning the truck immediately after the trip is extremely important if you want to avoid rust and any permanent damage to your vehicle. Most people act lazy and end up working harder than required to truck clean. Sometimes you may have to take it to professionals for stubborn stains. Checkout Four Simple Ideas Help You To Truck Clean After Off-Roading Trip: If you want to avoid extra expenses, here are some effective tips to truck clean after an off-roading tour. 1. Pressure Wash As Quickly As Possible When you get back to the road after an adventurous trip in the rough terrain, make sure you take your truck for a pressure wash. You can do it yourself at home or take your truck to the cleaning station where professionals will thoroughly truck clean. Pressure washing will remove the dirt, mud, and debris from every nook and corner. A regular wash might not be as effective as a pressure wash. If you keep your truck covered with mud and dirt for too long, its body may be damaged and you might end up increasing your expenses. 2. Inspect The Vehicle Thoroughly After the pressure wash, you will be able to see a neat and truck clean. Now you can inspect your truck thoroughly. Make sure you check the underbelly, the exterior body of the truck, engine, and radiator, and other sensitive parts that might have a chance of damage in rough terrain. This thorough inspection can help you fix the problems before they become bigger issues. You might have doubted some trouble during the trip, now would be a good time to get it checked and fixed before it gets worse. 3. Use Surface Protectant Pressure washing your vehicle is not enough. You need to polish the entire body of the truck with a surface protectant. You can explore the market and look for the perfect sealant for your truck before you take it on another adventure. When choosing the surface protectant, check out its ingredients. A silicon dioxide formula would be great for window shields, paint, and wheels. It also lasts longer than simple wax. Apply the seal on cold and wet surfaces. Clean with a microfiber towel to avoid water marks. 4. Clean The Interior Completely Cleaning the interior of your truck is just as important as the exterior. When you are on an off-road trip, the majority of your time is spent inside the truck. You might eat and sleep in the truck. Therefore, it might get dirty. Oil, sweat, and food crumbs can make the interior dirty and smelly. You can vacuum clean the interior by yourself. Make sure that you are using car floor mats rubber instead of carpet. Rubber mats are much easier to clean and they look as good as new after every wash. Moreover, they will not trap any smell as a carpet does. Read Also: How Crane Trucks Can Drastically Improve Project Efficiency4 Things You Need To Know About Commercial Truck InsuranceWhat to Do if You’re in an Accident with a Placarded Truck in Tampa

READ MOREDetails
inland rail

Effect of Australia’s New Inland Rail on the Trucking Industry

Spanning 18,000 Km from the east coast to the west coast, Australia is the fifth largest country in the world. Incidentally, the bulk of the population is settled in major cities along the coastline. The vast distances between major cities in Australia led to the development of the country’s robust inland freight networks. Australia plays a key role in the global economy and is the 20th largest exporter in the world. In 2017, the country made a positive trade balance of $44 B after exporting $243 B and importing $199 B worth of products. The country relies on its road and rail networks to mobilize all these products across the country efficiently. Significance of the Melbourne to Brisbane Inland Rail In a bold inland rail project to link Melbourne and Brisbane, Australia has invested about $10 Billion. The project will cover 1,700 kilometers to connect more than 20 major towns across three states, namely Victoria, New South Wales, and Queensland. The inland rail will streamline several bottlenecks and time constraints that have hampered freight transport between Melbourne and Brisbane. The project is also expected to create more than 10,000 jobs and boost Australia’s GDP by more than $16 Billion in 50 years. Australia’s Road Vs Rail Debate The development of the inland rail has fuelled the road vs rail debate in the freight industry. The debate questions on the efficiency and costs of using trains over trucks. Additionally, there is a concern on whether the new inland rail will put the heavy-duty truckers out of business. However, there is a lot of room in the country for both systems to coexist. With a few relevant adjustments, the road and rail systems can be integrated and complement each other. In effect, the new rail system in effect may enhance the trucking industry rather than retard it. Advantages of Rail and Road Freight Systems Both road and rail freight systems have niches where they can outdo each other. The following list highlights a few areas where it is advantageous to use road over rail transport and vice versa. Advantages of Road Transport 1. Efficient over short distances: Road transport offers several flexibility advantages that trains cannot match. Trains operate on a fixed rail line that cannot handle door to door deliveries. 2. Fast Scheduled Delivery: Trucks can deliver goods according to your schedule. This can save you from unnecessary storage costs. With rail transport, you have to adjust your programs to fit the train’s schedule. Advantages of Rail Transport 1. Cost-effective over long distances Using trains beats trucks over long distances. Trains carry more cargo and are up to 4 times more fuel-efficient than trucks. Also, the wear on your aftermarket parts for European trucks can be expensive over long distances. 2. Eco-Friendly: Trains are more environmentally friendly than trucks as they emit up to 75% fewer greenhouse gases. Also, trucks consume close to 9 times more energy per tonne-kilometer than trains. There are several ways in which the trucking industry can adapt to benefit from the development of Australia’s new inland rail system. For example, there will be immense opportunities to move cargo from to and from the train stations. Truck operators can extend the life of their vehicles and duration between services by plying shorter routes. Read Also: Freight Factoring Is Solving Common Trucking Challenges What To Consider When Buying Heavy Duty Truck Alignment Equipment Why Times Are Tough For Truckers And Why It Concerns You

READ MOREDetails